Can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? (2024)

By itresourcescorpcomBlog, Interview Tips, Job Search Guide

Can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? As IT recruiters, candidates ask us this question fairly often. In short, yes, this situation can occur. However, typically it is rare.

When candidates have a challenging list of changes to the initial offer, hiring managers may rethink their decision. We recommend doing proper research on how to negotiate salary in an interview to avoid any second thoughts.

Here are six tips on negotiating salary without losing the job offer.

6 Tips on Negotiating Salary Before the Interview

1. Do Your Research

Before you even have the interview, do your research. Look up the company on sources like Glassdoor to get an idea of what they pay their employees. Some job postings share their salary ranges while others don’t. Even if they do, look at what other positions offer in similar locations.

Locations and cost of living can heavily influence a salary. However, with the pandemic influencing the increase of remote positions, some salary trends have changed.

When candidates research salaries, sometimes they mistakenly think that a salary in San Francisco can apply toward a salary in Florida. They thus ask for a higher range and additional benefits, leading to hiring managers changing their minds. When you’re looking up how to negotiate salary in an interview, keep in mind the cost of living.

2. Know what to say when negotiating salary

Practice what to say when negotiating salary beforehand. Keep in mind most employers and hiring managers to practice negotiating salary as a part of their jobs. In other words, they’re used to it.

They will not feel shocked when you start negotiating. After knowing how much to ask for, start practicing so you know what to say and you feel confident saying it. Always be professional. Make a note of what you are willing to accept, your goal, and your bottom line.

3. Look at the total package

It’s not just about the salary. Part of the negotiation can be about your benefits. How much PTO do you receive? Do they offer a sign-on or performance bonus? If you feel unsatisfied with the answers to those questions, consider negotiating.

When questioning can you lose a job when negotiating salary, keep in mind it might not necessarily be the salary that you lose the position. For example, a professor was denied employment because she asks for both an increase in salary and benefits. If you choose to negotiate benefits, do it similarly as you would when researching salary.

4. Make it prompt

Responsiveness matters. The hiring managers will look at your level of interest and your enthusiasm while you negotiate. If you take too long to respond, it can appear as if you lost interest. They then might move on to a different candidate.

5. Do it in person

Referring back to the professor, the conversation occurred over email. Although she had a lengthy list of requests, you could assume through her language she wanted to negotiate. Instead, not only did the college deny her request, they revoked her offer entirely.

By negotiating in person, you can read a person when you begin to negotiate and determine if they feel displeased. You can thus continue the negotiation process to let them know that’s not your bottom line. Furthermore, you don’t give them time to consider revoking the offer.

6. Get it in writing

Although also rare, some companies change what you agreed upon. Get it in writing and ask for the whole package’s written documentation. Some companies may deliver this automatically. However, if not, be sure to ask for it.

How to Negotiate Salary in the Interview

When the next step of the interview process comes along, have your research handy. Know how much you deserve and don’t be ready to sell yourself short. You might think you’re worth $75,000 while the hiring manager thinks the position’s bottom line is $90,000.

When learning how to negotiate salary in an interview, we recommend not immediately disclosing how much you made in your last role. Not too many recruiters or hiring managers for this number. Some recruiters might when candidates come to them asking for potential jobs.

However, if they continue to press about past salaries and do not look at skills or qualifications, you might need to reconsider. A company that only cares about protecting its money without doing its own research may not be a good fit.

Lastly, when it comes to what to say when negotiating salary, wait until the second interview or once the company has given you an offer to talk about compensation. Be firm and polite. Do not be afraid to ask for more if the numbers do not match what they ask.

Your IT Career Counselor

So can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? Although the answer is yes contact a recruiter. They can help guide you through the salary ranges of a role in a specific location or company. Furthermore, if you fall into the Florida IT sector, our career counselors can help you plan out your goals today.

IT Resources works hard to place IT, professionals, with the industry’s top companies nationwide. We give you our attention through your job search, the interview process, and through negotiating salary. We can help polish up your resume, interviewing skills, and get you ready to help negotiate salary. You’re never just a number to us.

Can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? (2024)

FAQs

Can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? ›

The job offer tends only to be rescinded if the candidate is “negotiating for the sake of negotiating” or the number they are proposing is unreasonable. To avoid this outcome, remain polite and respectful. And as mentioned above, do your research to ensure the salary you ask for is fair.

Can you lose an offer if you negotiate salary? ›

So, can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? Technically yes, though it's highly unlikely if you do it right. One thing is for certain: you won't get what you want if you don't ask for it!

Can you get rejected for negotiating salary? ›

​Rhoades advises to always 'bear in mind…they might say no'. Throughout the conversation with your employer or hiring manager, from introducing the subject of a raise to negotiating, it is important to consider they may refuse and have measures in place to end the discussion on a positive note.

Is it OK to negotiate salary when offered a job? ›

Negotiating a job offer can feel uncomfortable, but most employers are open to candidates doing it. Most job candidates don't negotiate, but the vast majority who do get better offers than they had before.

Have not heard back after salary negotiation.? ›

Sometimes, when following up on a salary negotiation, you may encounter challenges or changes. For instance, you may not hear back from the employer after sending your follow-up message. In this case, you should wait a few days before trying to contact them again, and use a different method if possible.

Does HR expect you to negotiate salary? ›

What is this? But you should know that in almost every case, the company expects you to negotiate and it's in your best interest to give it a shot. In fact, a study by Salary.com found 84% of employers expect job applicants to negotiate salary during the interview stage.

Can an employer take back a job offer? ›

Yes, but there could be legal consequences, so an attorney's advice should always be sought before rescinding the offer. Even if an employer has stated on all offers that employment is at will and can be terminated at any time, there is the concept of the employer making a "promise" of a job.

When should you not negotiate your salary? ›

This will give you time to prove your worth and demonstrate your value to the company. When the company is in financial trouble: If a company is experiencing financial hardships, such as during an economic downturn, it may not be the best time to negotiate salary.

What not to do when negotiating a job offer? ›

  1. Make The First Offer. ...
  2. Use Another Offer As A Bargaining Chip. ...
  3. Share The Least Amount Of Money You'll Take. ...
  4. Focus Only On The Number. ...
  5. Start Negotiating Without Doing Your Research. ...
  6. Give A Salary Range. ...
  7. Misrepresent Your Value Or Previous Earnings. ...
  8. Get Defensive Or Emotional.
Aug 11, 2022

Should you ever accept the first salary offer? ›

Don't accept the first offer — they expect you to negotiate and salary is always negotiable.” “That's just not true,” says Weiss. Sure, much of the time there is an opportunity to negotiate, but some hiring managers genuinely give you the only number they can offer. The best way to find out, says Weiss, is to inquire.

When negotiating salary, how much is too much? ›

Strive for agreement and harmony in your negotiation and that you appreciate their offer and that you are negotiating to benefit both the company and you. Overall, we recommend that you start with a figure that's no more than 10-20% above the initial salary.

How to counter a job offer salary? ›

How to Negotiate a Salary Counter Offer
  1. Pause before responding.
  2. Ask a follow-up question.
  3. Turn the salary expectation question around.
  4. Get the salary range.
  5. Conduct comparative salary research.
  6. Prepare an organized argument.
  7. Ask for a 10-to-20-percent bump.
  8. Look for non-salary levers to pull.

How do you respond to a low salary offer? ›

How to respond to a low salary offer
  1. Ask for time. ...
  2. Understand your minimum acceptable salary. ...
  3. Conduct research. ...
  4. Make a plan. ...
  5. Practice negotiations. ...
  6. Show enthusiasm. ...
  7. Negotiate for early performance reviews. ...
  8. Focus on your skills and expertise.
Feb 2, 2024

Can salary negotiation lead to rejection? ›

A survey by Fidelity Investments found that 87% of young professionals who negotiated salaries received at least some of what they asked for. But negotiations can fail. However, other compensation options exist even if the company rejected your salary request. You can also try again in the future.

How long should salary negotiations last? ›

The full process for negotiating salary for a job offer can take 5 to 10 days or approximately 2 weeks. The process breaks down into multiple steps. First, there is a final interview. A few days to 1 week after the final interview comes the employment decision and initial offer.

What to do after a failed salary negotiation? ›

Most salary negotiations are successful, but some fail. Don't lose hope if the company rejects your salary negotiation and you still have to take the job. Be gracious in your reply while mentioning that the compensation was below expectations. Suggest compensation in other areas or future renegotiation opportunities.

How much over a job offer can you negotiate? ›

Overall, we recommend that you start with a figure that's no more than 10-20% above the initial salary. If the pay is in-line with average pay, but you believe you can negotiate based on your skills and experience, consider a range between 5-7% above.

Can I negotiate salary with another offer? ›

You should start with your top choice and communicate your interest and appreciation, but also mention that you have other competitive offers and ask if they can improve their offer. You should use your market value and your other offers as leverage, but avoid making ultimatums or threats.

Will a company pull an offer if you ask for more money? ›

Negotiating salary is a very normal thing to do. Candidates do it all the time, employers aren't typically surprised by it, and it almost never ends in the offer being pulled.

When not to negotiate a higher salary? ›

Here are seven situations when you should not negotiate your salary: When the salary is already significantly above market rate: When your salary is already higher than what other people in the same job get paid, asking for more money might not be a good idea.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Sen. Ignacio Ratke

Last Updated:

Views: 6125

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Sen. Ignacio Ratke

Birthday: 1999-05-27

Address: Apt. 171 8116 Bailey Via, Roberthaven, GA 58289

Phone: +2585395768220

Job: Lead Liaison

Hobby: Lockpicking, LARPing, Lego building, Lapidary, Macrame, Book restoration, Bodybuilding

Introduction: My name is Sen. Ignacio Ratke, I am a adventurous, zealous, outstanding, agreeable, precious, excited, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.